In public-sector consultancy, winning a place on a framework can open a door without bringing a realistic chance of work. RedQuadrant says it is listed on more than ten frameworks and over 400 procurement portals, yet estimates that it now sees only 5–10 per cent of the openly advertised consultancy tenders it encountered when it began trading in 2009. The firm says it ranks among the ten most frequent recipients of Crown Commercial Service tender notifications, making it unlikely, ...
Continue Reading This Article
Enjoy this article as well as all of our content, including reports, news, tips and more.
By registering or signing into your SRM Today account, you agree to SRM Today's Terms of Use and consent to the processing of your personal information as described in our Privacy Policy.
The company estimates that 75–85 per cent of framework call-offs in its area of consultancy are awarded without a further competition. That figure is its own assessment, not a sector-wide measurement. But it points to a distinction at the heart of public procurement: admission to a framework makes a supplier eligible; it does not ensure that buyers will invite it to compete for individual contracts.
National Audit Office analysis of central government procurement found that, in 2021–22, 72 per cent of contracts by number were awarded through frameworks or dynamic purchasing systems, while 14 per cent used open procedures. The NAO says frameworks can make buying quicker and reduce administrative work, but their rules may allow buyers to award some contracts without reopening competition. A framework with too few suppliers may not produce a meaningful contest; one with too many can make it difficult to identify the right provider. In either case, a place on the list is no guarantee of paid work.
The rules do, however, place limits on when a call-off can be made without a further competition. Government guidance under the Procurement Act 2023 says such an award is generally permitted only when the framework has a single supplier or sets out an objective method for choosing between suppliers, alongside the relevant core terms. Rotation and ranking systems are among the mechanisms that can qualify. Contract award notices are generally required, including information on whether the buyer ran a competition or made an award without one.
That framework process is distinct from a direct award made outside a competitive tender. Government guidance says direct awards can be used only on specified legal grounds, with a transparency notice normally required beforehand to explain the authority’s intention and justification. In other words, a direct award is not a general alternative for buyers who have already settled on a preferred supplier.
RedQuadrant’s argument is more about candour than unrestricted discretion. Its author says an openly acknowledged award, where legally permitted, may be preferable to spending days preparing a bid for a contest whose result appears effectively decided. The same author concedes that a company benefits when it receives a direct award, while wishing for a fair opportunity when another supplier is favoured.
The pressures on buyers are real, but the evidence does not establish that they explain the fall in advertised consultancy tenders. The Local Government Association’s January 2025 survey found that 71 per cent of responding council chief finance officers considered setting a balanced budget for 2025–26 very or fairly difficult. Confidence in funding statutory duties fell sharply when respondents looked to 2026–27. Those figures document financial strain; they do not measure consultancy purchasing or prove that budget pressures caused fewer open competitions.
Nor is artificial intelligence a single, settled explanation. The LGA’s 2025 research found councils using or exploring AI across functions including administration, finance, procurement and social care. Its findings describe varied activity, rather than showing that AI has displaced consultancy work. Public bodies may be trialling new tools, waiting for policy or funding decisions, or handling more work in-house, but the available evidence does not establish how much each factor has contributed to changes in the market.
A further difficulty is the advantage that can accrue to an incumbent. A supplier already known to a buyer has a record of delivery and familiarity with the organisation; a newcomer may have neither. Research recorded by the University of Warwick on recurrent contracts in London’s bus market examines how experience, sunk entry costs and switching costs can shape later competition. It is not a study of consultancy procurement, but it offers a relevant warning: repeated awards can alter the conditions under which future suppliers compete.
The NAO has also highlighted the costs and complexity of a crowded framework landscape. Thousands of frameworks are available, without a definitive count at the time of its review. Suppliers may spend heavily to secure admission, while buyers face overlapping routes and variable oversight. The NAO cautions that rising framework use does not, by itself, demonstrate better value for money; it has also raised concerns that provider commissions may create incentives favouring direct awards over call-off competitions.
The proposed remedies go beyond telling suppliers to research where money is spent. That advice may help a bidder avoid pursuing work already earmarked for another provider, but it does little to correct the information imbalance that grows when the incumbent gets another contract and another opportunity to understand the client.
One proposal is to let a trusted adviser help a buyer define its needs, while requiring that adviser’s firm to sit out the subsequent tender. Another is to use a draw among qualified suppliers for some small, fixed-price assignments. Buyers could also disclose whom they favour and what evidence might change their minds, giving other firms a route to challenge the preference; where nothing could do so, the buyer would have to explain that position publicly.
Other suggestions shift influence towards those affected by the work: frontline staff and service users could hold a majority on selection panels and help set the criteria. Repeat awards could also be reviewed with the employees who used the supplier’s advice, so future decisions reflect delivery rather than familiarity alone.
The central question is not simply whether a supplier has made it on to a framework. It is whether the process for each contract gives credible alternatives a genuine chance, and whether buyers can show how their decisions were made.
Source: Noah Wire Services



