For convenience-store operators, supplier negotiations are not just about securing a lower price. Freight, payment schedules, rebates, promotional support, equipment, service standards and delivery terms can all affect the value of a deal , and, across a large store network, small improvements can add up quickly.
The scale of the US industry makes those details consequential. The National Association of Convenience Stores (NACS) says the sector generated $817.5 billion in sales...
Continue Reading This Article
Enjoy this article as well as all of our content, including reports, news, tips and more.
By registering or signing into your SRM Today account, you agree to SRM Today's Terms of Use and consent to the processing of your personal information as described in our Privacy Policy.
Those negotiations are taking place amid rising costs. NACS reported that direct store operating expenses increased by 4.2% in 2025 and card fees reached a record $21.3 billion. A separate NACS Magazine analysis of the industry’s performance said total transaction numbers fell by 3% that year, adding to the pressure on operators to protect profitability and scrutinise costs.
John Matthews, founder and president of Raleigh-based consultancy Gray Cat Enterprises, draws on more than 30 years in convenience retail and other sectors to argue that preparation is the foundation of an effective negotiation. During his time at Clark Retail Enterprises and White Hen Pantry, which operated about 1,400 stores, he dealt with suppliers ranging from beverage companies and distributors to contractors, landlords and equipment makers.
The first task, he says, is to understand the economics of the deal and decide which outcomes are essential, which would be helpful and where the limit lies. Suppliers may seek more than a purchase order: they could value access to additional locations, stronger shelf placement, wider menu presence or preferred-supplier status. Those commitments have commercial worth and should be weighed against what the retailer is asking for.
Harvard Law School’s Program on Negotiation advises negotiators to assess their alternatives before talks begin and establish the point at which walking away would be preferable. Its guidance also stresses considering the other party’s likely options and constraints, rather than concentrating solely on one’s own demands. That kind of preparation can help negotiators pursue ambitious terms without making an agreement unattainable.
A systematic review of 427 academic papers on bargaining in purchasing and supply management, published in the Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, similarly treats negotiation as more than a contest over price. It distinguishes between approaches focused on claiming value and those aimed at finding gains for both parties, noting that negotiators may shift between the two. The authors also identify preparation, information, trust and the quality of the ongoing supplier relationship as relevant factors, while cautioning that their review maps the research rather than establishing cause and effect.
During discussions, calm and attentive listening can reveal room for movement even when a supplier cannot reduce its headline price. Better freight arrangements, longer payment periods, rebates, marketing contributions, training or equipment may offer value elsewhere in the deal. Harvard’s Program on Negotiation recommends paraphrasing what the other party has said, asking questions and acknowledging concerns to check understanding and uncover the interests behind a stated position.
A pause can be useful, too. The Harvard programme describes silence as a way to absorb an offer, avoid a reflexive response and consider what to ask next. If a proposed term is unfavourable, a measured pause may be more productive than an immediate rebuke. The point is not to use silence as a guaranteed tactic, but to keep emotion from crowding out judgement.
Clarity matters just as much. Retailers should explain what they need and why, while making sure expectations are specific enough to avoid misunderstandings later. If a discussion stalls, postponing a decision to gather information or bring in the right people may be wiser than forcing a resolution without a clear view of the consequences.
The aim, Matthews argues, is not to leave a supplier unable to invest or provide reliable service. A deal that damages the other side’s economics can undermine the relationship on which future supply depends. As foodservice grows in importance to in-store profitability and operating costs continue to rise, retailers have reason to examine the full commercial picture rather than pursuing the lowest invoice price in isolation.
The strongest agreement may differ from the one either party expected at the outset. For operators, the durable benefit lies in reaching terms that meet immediate business needs while giving both sides a reason to keep working together.
Source: Noah Wire Services



