Poorly defined contract scope can damage both sides of a commercial relationship, but it is only one part of a much wider failure to turn agreements into value.
Buyers may face escalating charges and late variations; suppliers, meanwhile, can find themselves doing extra work without compensation. When requests appear individually minor, they may go unchallenged until their cumulative cost becomes substantial. Yet the reverse can happen too: a supplier may contribute more than t...
Continue Reading This Article
Enjoy this article as well as all of our content, including reports, news, tips and more.
By registering or signing into your SRM Today account, you agree to SRM Today's Terms of Use and consent to the processing of your personal information as described in our Privacy Policy.
World Commerce & Contracting’s 2026 research with Ironclad estimates that organisations lose an average of 11% of contract value. The figure reflects a range of problems rather than a single breakdown. Unauthorised or unrecorded changes account for an estimated 2–3%, alongside similar losses from weak negotiation and inadequate renewal planning. Other sources include benefits that are agreed but never activated, untracked price adjustments, missed obligations and damage to relationships and innovation.
That means tighter change control, on its own, cannot close the gap. It addresses only one element of the losses. WorldCC’s report also presents leakage as a consequence of weak ownership and oversight after signature: responsibility for delivering contractual value can be fragmented across procurement, legal, commercial and operational teams, leaving commitments without effective follow-through.
The imbalance is not always captured in formal variations. Gene Turner, writing for WorldCC, calls “scope seep” the unpriced value suppliers sometimes add voluntarily when they believe they can deliver a better result than the one specified. The term is Turner’s, rather than WorldCC’s. In professional services, suppliers may feel obliged to provide their best work even when the client has contracted for less. Without a way to acknowledge or share the resulting benefit, that contribution can go unrewarded.
Pricing based on hours, resources or deliverables can also discourage improvement. If a supplier uses automation or a better method to achieve the same result with less effort, an effort-based fee may leave the customer with all the financial gain. The supplier may then face pressure to reduce its price at renewal precisely because it has become more efficient.
Research cited by Turner on supplier-led innovation suggests that contractual language alone does not solve this problem. Although innovation and continuous-improvement provisions are common, respondents often regard them as ineffective. Suppliers have also reported holding back ideas when incentives are absent or customers appear unreceptive. The issue is therefore not just whether an agreement contains an innovation clause, but whether the relationship gives both sides a practical reason and a workable route to act on it.
WorldCC’s research on smarter contracts reinforces the importance of post-signature financial oversight. A survey of nearly 200 organisations found that around 70% recognised a disconnect between contracts and financial performance. The report says organisations that use contracts as a source of financial intelligence outperform peers by an average of 5.4% of contract value. Its broader message is that contractual commitments need to be monitored as commercial obligations, not left as legal terms whose job ends when a deal is signed.
A more effective approach starts before the price is agreed. WorldCC’s Ten Pitfalls material identifies unclear scope and goals as a recurrent source of claims and disputes. Parties should establish together what problem they are trying to solve and what outcome would count as success. If they cannot express that clearly, a detailed schedule may create the appearance of precision without resolving the underlying uncertainty.
Turner also recommends presenting distinct options rather than a single proposed package. Different levels of service or ambition can expose what the buyer values most and make the trade-offs visible. Contracts should state what falls outside the agreed scope and allocate responsibilities clearly, rather than relying on a long list of caveats.
Where outcomes can be measured, pricing can be tied more closely to them, with gains from improvements shared between the parties. But such arrangements require governance capable of checking whether the promised results have materialised. Otherwise, a gain-share or continuous-improvement provision risks becoming another negotiated benefit that is never used.
Change procedures matter as well. A clear process for submitting, assessing and approving variations can protect both sides while allowing work to adapt as circumstances change. But a process that makes every proposal slow or adversarial may deter suppliers from raising worthwhile ideas. WorldCC’s guidance on adaptive contracting favours a structured workflow that enables decisions, rather than an improvised negotiation that turns every change into a contest.
Nor does transferring risk through contract language necessarily manage it. WorldCC’s value-gap report warns that assigning liability determines who bears the consequences; it does not ensure that the underlying risk is controlled. A contract can provide a framework for managing a relationship, but it cannot replace active oversight, clear accountability and communication.
The practical test for contract owners is broader than whether variations are being approved correctly. They must also ask whether suppliers have contributed unrecognised value, whether negotiated benefits are being used, and whether the agreement rewards improvements that serve both parties. Without those checks, a contract can remain compliant on paper while its commercial promise quietly goes unrealised.
Source: Noah Wire Services



